Mod-Moms-Club-logo-whitemod-moms-club-stacked-logo-white
New to Mod Moms Club? Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest parenting news, advice, and resources.
Mod-Moms-Club-logomod-moms-club-stacked-logo
More

A College Admissions Expert Reveals Which Extracurricular Activities Actually Impress Top Schools

Ryan Brennan | January 12, 2026

A college admissions expert is spilling the beans on high school extracurriculars. 

As many students know, filling out a college application is one of the most stressful tasks when going through the college admissions process — after all, it could make or break your dream scenario. 

But taking part in the right extracurricular activities can certainly give you a leg up on other applicants. 

“Independent and special projects are pure gold in admissions,” Kate Stone, founder of Kate Stone Prep, wrote in a May 7 Instagram post where she ranked high school extracurriculars on a scale from 1 to 10. 

READ MORE: Expert parenting advice for supporting teens through the college admissions process

“Showing up for ONLY school‑sponsored clubs or ‘because it looks good’ won’t distinguish you in this process — it just blends you into a crowd of sameness,” she added. 

Stone went on to post a second video where she ranked even more extracurriculars on Nov. 3. 

Here’s a full list of all the activities she ranked — and how she ranked them: 

  • Becoming the leader of a club with significant impact: 10/10
  • Winning club competitions: 10/10
  • Year-round sports if you’re going D1: 10/10
  • Shadowing professionals: 10/10
  • Building a network of mentors: 10/10
  • Solving a real-world problem in your community: 10/10
  • Playing viola: 9/10
  • Taking an independent online course or college course: 8/10
  • Playing an instrument at a competitive state or national level: 8/10
  • Volunteering with a cause you’re passionate about: 7/10
  • Newspaper editor: 7/10
  • Planning your prom: 7/10
  • Internships: 7/10
  • Eagle Scout: 6/10
  • Student council: 5/10
  • Model U.N. and debate: 5/10
  • Deca: 5/10
  • Being captain of a sport’s team: 4/10
  • Tutoring: 4/10
  • Becoming the leader of a club without significant impact: 3/10
  • Working as a camp counselor: 3/10
  • Working as a lifeguard: 3/10
  • Playing an instrument: 3/10
  • Year-round sports: 3/10
  • Robotics: 3/10
  • Playing violin: 3/10
  • Volunteering just to log hours: 2/10

Stone appeared to prefer anything that forces students to be creative and “different” from others.

“These are the activities that don’t just “look good” but force you to become the type of person who is attractive to elite universities,” she wrote in her Nov. 3 Instagram post. 

“Limiting yourself to school-sponsored clubs and activities won’t set you apart,” she added. 

More tips when selecting the right high school extracurriculars

a group of kids playing chess high school extracurriculars
Bm Creatives / Pexels

In an interview with TODAY.com, Stone revealed the key ingredient when it comes to extracurriculars. 

"Anything that thousands of kids are doing is always going to be less helpful for you," Stone said, further placing an emphasis on independent work and special projects. 

She went on to list several of her top tips for students when looking at extracurricular activities. 

The three main factors are to find something that differentiates yourself, something that you’re truly passionate about and something that makes a lasting, measurable impact on the community. 

But if students really want to impress their target schools, there’s on extracurricular that reigns supreme. 

"The new extracurricular is having a mentor," Stone told TODAY.com. "If I could advise parents one thing, find your kid a mentor that you know will inspire them."

Having a mentor in your area of interest exposes students to real-life advice from someone who has been there — and someone who is doing it at a high level. 

ALSO ON MOD MOMS CLUB: Single dad reveals the one rule that helped him raise an 11-year-old college graduate

But at the end of the day, Stone argues : "It’s not about the extracurricular. It’s what you do with the extracurricular."

Related Articles
February 10, 2026
Why the Best Gift You Can Give Your Kids Might Cost Less Than You Think

That camping trip your family still talks about? Science says it’s worth more than any toy under the tree.

Read More
February 4, 2026
The Best Bedroom Paint Colors to Help Your Whole Family Sleep Better

Your bedroom paint color could be sabotaging your sleep. Experts explain which shades promote rest—and which may be keeping you awake.

Read More
February 3, 2026
Do Babies Really Sleep Better Outside? What Scandinavian Parents (and Research) Say

“As someone in America, people really need to realize that different places have different cultures and traditions."

Read More
1 2 3 119
Shop Mod Moms Club
all-products Dopple Hubble
All Products
travel-and-transport Bravo Dopple
Travel & Transport
toys-and-activity Dopple
Toys & Activities
Hubble sound machine
Nursery Design
Chicco-Lullaby-Zip-Changer_1_720x
Sleeping
Dopple clothing picture
Clothing
Mod-Moms-Club-logo-white
mod-moms-club-stacked-logo-white
Connect with us
tiktok-logo-icon-white
TheQuietMinute-Logo-White
Catch up on the latest in entertainment and parenting with our weekly newsletter.
Subscribe To Our Newsletter
Copyright @ 2025 ModMomsClub.com
crosscross-circleplus-circlecircle-minus